Auburndale, FL - Polk County detectives have arrested 39-year-old Andrew “Drew” McGaffigan, an active member of the First Baptist Church of Auburndale, on 76 counts of possessing child pornography. The arrest follows an expanded investigation by the Polk County Sheriff’s Office after a tip from the National Center for Missing and Endangered Children.
Discovery of Child Porn on Church Member's Phone
McGaffigan was first taken into custody on December 17 on 30 counts related to child sexual abuse materials. Detectives seized his phone and other electronic devices, later conducting a deeper forensic search that uncovered 46 additional illegal images and videos. Investigators say one video depicted a child being forced into sexual acts with a dog.
Authorities confirmed that the victims in the files ranged from six months old to 12 years old.
Sheriff Judd Condemns Clergy Sex Abuse
Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd condemned the disturbing findings, describing McGaffigan’s alleged crimes as “the worst of the worst.” He emphasized the gravity of the case, noting that McGaffigan is married, has children, and is an active church member.
“Here is a married man with children of his own advocating for the sexual abuse of babies and children,” Judd said. “We will continue our thorough investigation to determine whether or not he has abused any child to whom he has access.”
Ongoing Investigation
Detectives have not found any connection between McGaffigan and the victims depicted in the material. The investigation remains active, with authorities reviewing potential risks to children within his circle and his community ties at the First Baptist Church of Auburndale.
FL Attorney Explains Legal Options for Students Sexually Abused by Church Members
When accusations surface involving church members and student victims, many families are left unsure where to turn. Florida sexual abuse lawyer Michael Haggard discusses how the law protects young survivors and what steps families can take to hold both individual offenders and institutions accountable.
Laurence Banville: When a church member is accused of possessing or distributing child sexual abuse material, what steps can potential victims or their families take?
Michael Haggard: The first step is contacting law enforcement immediately if there’s any suspicion of direct abuse. Beyond the criminal process, survivors also have civil legal rights. Churches and affiliated institutions can sometimes be held liable if they failed to conduct background checks, ignored red flags, or failed to report misconduct. Civil lawsuits can help survivors recover damages for the trauma they’ve endured.
Banville: Many victims hesitate to come forward, especially when the accused is active in a trusted organization. What advice do you give them?
Haggard: That hesitation is understandable. But accountability often starts with a single report. Reaching out to an experienced sexual abuse attorney helps victims understand their privacy rights, available support, and possible paths for healing through both the courts and community resources.
Support for Survivors and Families
If you or a loved one has experienced sexual abuse by a church member or trusted adult, legal help is available. Our team stands ready to listen, guide, and fight for your rights. Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation and take the first step toward holding those responsible accountable.
