Harrisburg, IL - A former pastor of Lighthouse Apostolic Faith Church in Harrisburg, Illinois, is facing serious legal trouble following his arrest last month. Danny Varnadore, who recently stepped down from his pastoral duties, has been charged with two counts of criminal sexual assault.
Arrest and Upcoming Court Appearance
Varnadore was taken into custody in November by Eldorado police on a warrant issued out of Moultrie County. He is expected to appear in Moultrie County court next Monday for a preliminary hearing related to the charges. The case stems from allegations that date back nearly two years, when Varnadore was ministering at First Apostolic Church of Sullivan.
Church Issues Statement Amid Ongoing Case
Following Varnadore’s resignation, Lighthouse Apostolic Faith Church released a public statement acknowledging both his departure and the charges against him. The church expressed faith in Varnadore’s eventual vindication, citing its belief that the allegations are false.
“With unwavering faith and a spirit of resilience, we share this update,” the statement read. “After standing strong against false allegations made against Pastor Danny Varnadore Jr. nearly two years ago… he has stepped down from his position… trusting in God’s divine justice and ultimate vindication.”
Legal Options for Victims Sexually Abused by Clergy
When allegations of sexual abuse involve a religious leader, victims often face deep emotional conflict and community pressure. To better understand the legal avenues available in such cases, we sat down with Illinois sexual abuse lawyer Erv Nevitt. In this interview, Nevitt discusses how state laws protect survivors, the potential responsibility of religious institutions, and the steps victims can take to hold abusers accountable through both criminal and civil actions.
Laurence Banville, Esq.: When allegations involve a faith leader, many victims struggle with fear, shame, or pressure from the community. What legal paths are available to them?
Erv Nevitt, Esq.: Illinois law allows victims of sexual assault to take action through both criminal charges and civil lawsuits. Even if a case leads to prosecution, survivors can still pursue damages in civil court for emotional trauma, medical expenses, or loss of trust. Churches and religious organizations can also be held liable if they failed to act on prior warnings or complaints.
Banville: Do cases like this often depend on how much the institution knew?
Nevitt: Absolutely. If evidence shows church leadership ignored reports or enabled misconduct, liability increases. What matters most is empowering victims to come forward safely and ensuring they have legal support every step of the way.
Support and Legal Help for Survivors
No one should face the trauma of sexual abuse alone. Victims and their families can take the first step toward healing and accountability by understanding their legal rights. Our experienced legal team stands ready to listen, guide, and advocate for survivors of clergy abuse. Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation to discuss your options and begin the path toward justice and recovery.
