Harrisburg, PA - Pastor Michael Arthur McMullen Sr., 68, is facing serious criminal charges following allegations involving a juvenile on September 8.
Felony and Misdemeanor Charges Filed
According to court records, McMullen has been charged with Felony Unlawful Contact With a Minor, Misdemeanor Corruption of Minors, and Misdemeanor Indecent Assault of a Person Less Than 16 Years Old. The charges stem from an affidavit filed after an investigation by local authorities.
Allegations Detailed in Affidavit
Investigators reported that the juvenile, identified as C.B., said she was being fitted for a robe when McMullen allegedly measured her waist without consent, touched her chest, brushed against her buttocks, and ran his hand down her leg. The affidavit states he made a sexually explicit remark and licked his lips while speaking.
A forensic interview conducted at the UPMC Child Advocacy Center supported the claims, with the minor expressing that she believed McMullen “wanted sex from her.”
Court Proceedings and Bail Conditions
McMullen was arrested on November 18 and appeared before Magisterial District Judge Marian Urrutia for a preliminary arraignment at 2:45 p.m. His bail was set at $25,000 unsecured. Court records show his preliminary hearing, initially set for December 11, has been postponed to February 5, 2026, at 1:45 p.m.
Community Ties and Church Involvement
McMullen's public social media accounts identify him as a pastor at St. John AME Church and Executive Director of Robe Gifting International, along with several senior leadership positions in religious and business organizations.
His profile also references his attendance at the AME 1st District Aspire Youth Congress in July, a large youth-based church event held at the DoubleTree by Hilton in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. He announced his wedding the same day as the alleged incident and later shared that he married on October 11, 2025.
Background Information
McMullen’s online biography lists him as a Harrisburg resident originally from Washington, D.C., educated at Harrisburg High School, Fuller Theological Seminary, and the University of Arizona Global Campus.
Authorities have not released further details as the case continues to move through Dauphin County Court.
Understanding Legal Options for Victims of Sexual Abuse by Pastors
In light of the recent allegations against Harrisburg pastor Michael McMullen, the conversation surrounding the rights of sexual abuse victims has gained urgency. Experienced Pennsylvania sexual abuse lawyer, Max Morgan, explores the avenues available for victims seeking accountability. Morgan shares valuable information on legal actions, the significance of specialized representation, and the evolving landscape of laws surrounding these sensitive cases.
Laurence Banville, Esq.: When allegations like these surface involving a pastor or church official, what can victims do beyond the criminal process?
Max Morgan, Esq.: Victims have the right to file a civil lawsuit for damages in addition to cooperating with authorities in a criminal case. A civil claim can hold both the individual and the institution accountable if negligence or failure to protect occurred. It’s not just about punishment—it’s about recovery and acknowledgment of the harm done.
Banville: Are churches often held liable in these types of cases?
Morgan: Yes, if evidence shows the church ignored warning signs, failed to report allegations, or allowed unsupervised access to minors. Pennsylvania law permits survivors to pursue claims against organizations that enabled abuse through inaction or misconduct. It often takes a brave survivor coming forward to expose broader patterns of neglect.
Take Action: Legal Help Is Available
Survivors of clergy sexual abuse and their families should know they are not alone. Speaking with an experienced attorney can provide answers, guidance, and the support needed to begin rebuilding. Our legal team offers free, confidential consultations to help victims understand their rights and explore their options for justice. Contact us today to discuss your case and take the first step toward accountability and healing.
