Circle of Hope Girls Ranch: Abuse Survivors Rally for Trial, Opposing Plea Agreements

In a powerful display of resilience, survivors of alleged abuse at the now-closed Circle of Hope Girls Ranch in Missouri are making their voices heard. These former students are urging Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey to reject plea deals and proceed with a trial for Stephanie Householder, who co-owned the controversial boarding school.

Allegations of Sexual Abuse Case Background

Circle of Hope Girls Ranch, a former Christian boarding school for troubled teens in Cedar County, Missouri, has been at the center of a harrowing abuse scandal. Stephanie Householder faces 21 charges of child abuse and neglect, stemming from allegations made by former students.

The case took an unexpected turn when Boyd Householder, Stephanie’s husband and co-owner of the ranch, passed away due to a “cardiac incident” before facing trial. He had been charged with nearly 80 counts, including allegations of sexual abuse.

Survivors Demand Justice – Taking A Stand

Former students and advocates, including representatives from the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), have taken a stand against potential plea deals for Stephanie Householder. They delivered a letter to Attorney General Bailey, expressing their strong desire for a full trial to proceed.

David Clohessy, Missouri volunteer director for SNAP, expressed concerns that the attorney general might offer Householder another plea deal, following a rejected offer in 2023. However, the attorney general’s office has stated that there are currently “no pending offers of a plea deal.”

The Impact on Survivors of Sexual Abuse

The possibility of a plea deal has deeply affected survivors of the alleged abuse. Maggie Drew, a former resident of Circle of Hope from 2007 to 2013, described the prospect of a plea deal as “a huge slap in the face.” Drew recounted traumatic experiences at the ranch, including suffering broken bones and being told to “walk it off” by Householder.

The Call for a Trial

Amanda Householder, Stephanie’s daughter, wrote a letter on behalf of a group of survivors, emphasizing the importance of a trial:

“While the trial will be emotionally very hard for many of us in the short term, in the long run, we are convinced that it will be a powerful deterrent to others who might commit or conceal crimes against children.”

Broader Implications for Boarding School Oversight

This case has shed light on the broader issue of oversight in Christian boarding schools for troubled teens. Advocates are calling for more rigorous investigations into similar institutions across Missouri and beyond.

Legal Proceedings and Future Steps

Stephanie Householder is currently scheduled for a jury trial in October. The attorney general’s office has emphasized that Bailey only intervenes in criminal cases when appointed by the governor or local authorities.

The Circle of Hope Ranch abuse case represents a critical juncture in the fight against institutional child abuse. As survivors push for a full trial, their actions highlight the ongoing need for vigilance, accountability, and support for those who have experienced abuse in residential school settings.

Attorney Commentary From Our Partnered Law Firm

Ryan Frazier, Esq. of Monsees & Mayer P.C. shares his thoughts:

“Let me tell you, these cases are never easy. When survivors push for a trial, it’s because they’re seeking more than just a quick resolution – they’re looking for acknowledgment and justice. Now, plea deals have their place, but in cases of systemic abuse like this, a trial can shed light on issues that might otherwise stay in the shadows. It’s not just about one case; it’s about changing the system. As a lawyer, I’ve seen how a public trial can be a powerful tool for change. It’s tough on everyone involved, no doubt, but sometimes it’s the best path to real justice and prevention of future abuses.”

Source:

Missouri Independent