A federal lawsuit recently filed against Circle of Hope Girls Ranch, a shuttered Christian boarding school in Missouri, has brought renewed attention to the issue of abuse in religious schools and the lack of state oversight. The lawsuit, filed on behalf of an 18-year-old former student, alleges severe mistreatment, including “abuse, harassment, forced servitude, assault, fraud” by the school’s owners. This case is part of a larger pattern of abuse allegations against religious boarding schools in Missouri, raising serious questions about the state’s regulatory framework.
Disturbing Allegations
The 25-page civil lawsuit details shocking claims of abuse at Circle of Hope Girls Ranch. The plaintiff, identified as Jane Doe or Plaintiff D.A., was just 13 when she arrived at the facility. One particularly alarming incident described in the lawsuit involves Boyd Householder, one of the school’s owners, allegedly wrapping the plaintiff’s head with tape as punishment for singing a Christian song.
Widespread Problem
Circle of Hope is not an isolated case. Since 2020, the now-closed facility has faced at least 26 lawsuits in state and federal courts from former students alleging abuse. Another religious institution, Agape Boarding School for Boys, has been hit with at least 20 federal suits and 40 state court lawsuits containing similar claims.
Criminal Charges
The owners of Circle of Hope, Stephanie and Boyd Householder, were charged with more than 100 abuse-related felonies in 2021. While Boyd Householder has since passed away, Stephanie Householder is set to face a criminal trial later this year, accused of 21 felonies, including child abuse, neglect, and endangerment.
Call for Reform
The lawsuit and subsequent demonstration by abuse survivors at the federal courthouse in Springfield highlight the urgent need for increased state oversight of religious schools in Missouri. Currently, state law has relatively few regulations governing overnight-stay schools with religious ties. David Clohessy, a member of the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests (SNAP), emphasized the importance of survivors coming forward and reporting abuse to authorities.
Long-Term Impact
Robin Craycroft, a survivor who now works as a therapist in Springfield, underscored the lasting effects of sexual trauma. She explained that trauma can fundamentally alter a person’s perception of the world, making it seem like a dangerous place
Attorney Commentary Between Attorney Ryan Frazier and Laurence Banville
Laurence Banville: Ryan, this new lawsuit against Circle of Hope Girls Ranch is quite disturbing. What are your initial thoughts on the case?
Ryan Frazier: This case is deeply troubling, and unfortunately, it’s part of a larger pattern we’re seeing with religious schools in Missouri. The allegations here are not just about isolated incidents, but a systemic problem of abuse that allegedly went on for years.
Laurence Banville: What makes this case particularly significant from a legal standpoint?
Ryan Frazier: There are a few key aspects. First, we’re dealing with multiple defendants – not just the direct perpetrators but also those in positions of authority. The inclusion of Jeffrey Ables, a board member, as a defendant is noteworthy. It sends a strong message about the responsibility of those in oversight roles.
Laurence Banville: How does this case highlight the need for stronger oversight of religious schools in Missouri?
Ryan Frazier: It exposes a glaring gap in our state’s regulatory framework. Currently, Missouri has very few regulations governing religious boarding schools. This lack of oversight can create environments where abuse can potentially thrive unchecked. Cases like this underscore the urgent need for reform.
Laurence Banville: What impact do you think this lawsuit might have beyond seeking justice for the plaintiff?
Ryan Frazier: These lawsuits serve multiple purposes; they can provide some measure of justice and healing for survivors, drive policy changes in how we regulate these institutions, and, importantly, encourage other survivors to come forward. It’s about creating systemic change to prevent future abuse.
Laurence Banville: What advice would you give to anyone who has experienced abuse in similar settings?
Ryan Frazier: My advice is simple but crucial: speak out. There are resources and support systems available. While the legal process can be daunting, it’s also a powerful tool for change. Remember, your voice matters, and it’s never too late to seek justice. Reaching out to a trusted person, law enforcement, or organizations like SNAP can be a good first step.
Laurence Banville: Thank you, Ryan, for sharing your insights on this important case.
Ryan Frazier: Thank you, it’s crucial that we keep shining a light on these issues and work towards better protections for vulnerable children in our state.
Source:
Mr. Banville is a personal injury attorney who has experience in handling auto accidents, work injuries, medical malpractice, dog bites, slip and falls, and representing survivors and victims of sexual abuse. Mr. Banville is affiliated with law firms in Pennsylvania, New York, New Jersey, Delaware, D.C., and Maryland. Abuse Guardian
